Showing posts with label supremecourt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label supremecourt. Show all posts

Friday, June 04, 2010

"Right to Remain Silent" changed by Supreme Court

It is a refrain familiar to anyone who has watched a cop show - "You have the right to remain silent." The right, enshrined by the Supreme Court, is to remain silent until speaking with a lawyer. But now, the Supreme Court has changed this right slightly by ruling that not explicitly invoking that right is equivalent to waiving the right. This has the potential to put additional pressure on the less educated who are arrested.

The high court upheld the murder conviction of a man who did not verbally assert his right to remain silent during his police interrogation. In a 5-4 ruling, the court said a suspect must explicitly tell officers he or she is asserting that right, known as Miranda rights.
My father was a lawyer and he always advised me that FIRST thing to do if arrested - whether you are innocent or guilty - is to ask for a lawyer. Otherwise, you risk unwittingly saying something to get yourself in trouble.

Wednesday, July 01, 2009

Supremes decline to kill Cable DVRs

Television and movie companies have always been nervous about consumer recording systems. There was a huge fight over the VCR - which the studios lost. Then, a battle over putting television shows online. Now, the studios are trying to kill network cable DVRs. But the Supreme Court has refused to hear a case that could have shut them down entirely.

The justices declined to hear arguments on whether Cablevision Systems Corp.'s remote-storage DVR system would violate copyright laws. The end to the closely watched case allows the Bethpage, N.Y.-based company to proceed with plans to start deploying the technology this summer.

With remote storage, TV shows are kept on the cable operator's servers instead of a machine inside the customer's home, as systems offered by TiVo Inc. and cable operators currently do.

The distinction is important because a remote system essentially transforms every digital set-top box in the home into a DVR, allowing customers to sign up instantly, without the need to pick up a DVR from the nearest cable office or wait for a technician to visit.
It is always a bad thing to fight the future, because it is coming whether you like it or not. Here's hoping this decision - or lack thereof - forces television and movie studios to engage digital device makers to bring about the best experience for consumers, while keeping things profitable for artists.

Friday, May 01, 2009

Supreme Court Justice David Souter to retire?

People have been expecting the older members of the Supreme Court to retire for some time now, but instead it appears that Supreme Court Justice David Souter will be the next one to leave the bench. This gives Obama his first chance to bring onto the court someone who reflects his own views. Although, while Justice Souter was nominated by President George H. W. Bush, a Republican and moderate conservative, Souter himself has consistently sided with the liberal-wing of the court. So, this change is unlikely to alter the landscape overall.

The question now is whether Conservatives will want payback for all of the justices that were filibustered and obstructed during the George W. Bush years. I am hoping that the GOP can rise above tit-for-tat, but I am not very hopeful in the current leadership's ability to do so. It is more likely they will want eye-for-an-eye and will stand in the way of any justice that President Obama nominates.

Friday, October 10, 2008

CT Supreme Court Rules Gay Marriage Ban Unconstitutional

That is right, folks. It is official. I knew it was coming, but it still is shocking to me. Nice to know the culture war will be coming to my home state for a while. Maybe it'll boost the economy for a bit. Even angry protesters need to eat and sleep somewhere, right?

Friday, April 27, 2007

Supreme Court on Partial-Birth Abortion Stirs Anti-Catholic Bigotry?

We here at Mod-Blog have applauded the Supremes' decision to uphold the Partial Birth Abortion ban, while maintaining that philosophically abortion should be placed back in the hands of the states rather than being a Federal issue. Overall, most of the reaction I have heard has been positive, but apparently the Justices who voted to uphold the ban are being attacked by the insinuation they only did so because they are Catholic. I have not read the various attacks on this basis, but as a Protestant I need to tell these critics that it is possible to think this decision is a good idea without being Catholic! I think that I hold a reasoned, considered opinion about abortion and especially partial birth abortion, which I believe I would hold even if I were an atheist.

Too bad. But ever since I first spoke up as Pro-Life in high school, most of my arguments with the other side wound up with them calling me names or spouting unreasoned, unexamined assumptions. I am told that is the experience of logical reasoned people on the Pro-Choice side, as well. Apparently, the vast majority can't talk about this issue without resorting to pure emotion. I am glad the Justices seem to NOT be cut from that cloth.

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

Partial Birth Abortion Ban Upheld by the Supremes!

My memory may be incorrect, but I seem to recall when Congress passed the Partial Birth Abortion ban it was generally seen as a symbolic move which would not survive court challenges. Well, apparently the Supreme Court felt differently. They ust uphold the ban 5-to-4.

For the first time since the court established a woman's right to an abortion in 1973, the justices upheld a nationwide ban on a specific abortion method, labeled partial-birth abortion by its opponents.
The 5-4 decision written by Justice Anthony Kennedy said the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act that Congress passed and President Bush signed into law in 2003 does not violate a woman's constitutional right to an abortion.
The law is constitutional despite not containing an exception that would allow the procedure if needed to preserve a woman's health, Kennedy said. "The law need not give abortion doctors unfettered choice in the course of their medical practice," he wrote in the majority opinion.
I am of two minds about this. On the one hand, I am of the opinion that the decision of legality of abortion should be a STATE issue, not a Federal one. On the other hand, I am glad for any glimmering of hope that the unborn can be protected.